
November 1970 saw the release of two albums. One was from an established guitar player looking to regain some anonymity whilst the other was from a solo artists trying to escape from it. We will come back the the first artist in the next post this month. The second though was a certain David Bowie.
Continuing on from last years What-If Super Deluxe Box Set of Bowie’s 1969 album, I thought it was time to have a look at the follow up as it is celebrating it 55th anniversary. That record was ‘The Man Who Sold The World’. Thinking back to last year, what I enjoyed most about the 2019 ‘Conversation Piece’ box set was the inclusion of numerous demo recording that Bowie had made between 1968 and 1969. 2021’s ‘The Width of a Circle’ box, which was the companion piece to ‘The Man Who Sold the World’ was a more sparse affair. ‘Conversation Piece’ was a lush five disc set, but ‘The Width of a Circle’ only included two. There was also a complete lack of demos. So what are we left with to produce this deluxe box set?
Well, we have the original 1970 album mix and three remasters of the album. Both the 1990 Rykosic and 2015 remasters are both included, but like on the ‘David Bowie’ box from last year, there is not much difference in the mixes for my untrained ears. 2020 did see a nearly whole album remix by Tony Visconti that was released under the albums supposed original name of ‘Metrobolist’. Only the song ‘After All’ was spared from the remix treatment as Visconit felt that the 2015 remaster was perfect as it was.
There are two BBC sessions. Some of these were released back in 2000 as part of the ‘Bowie at the Beeb’ set, but unlike that compilation which had highlights of the shows, these are now complete. We are lucky to have the The Sunday Show from 5th February 1970, as the BBC in its infinite wisdom did not keep a copy. This was recorded off of the radio by Tony Visconti. Where as that show focused a lot on material that Bowie had recorded for his 1969 album, the second BBC session, recorded less than two months later previews material that would mostly appear on ‘The Man Who Sold the World’. The exception being a cover of ‘Waiting for the Man’ by the Velvet Underground.
We also have the songs Bowie contributed to the televised version of Lindsay Kemp’s pantomime, ‘Pierrot in Turquoise’. This was only broadcast in Scotland and even though Bowie had had a hit with ‘Space Oddity’ he was not quite the household name. Bowie contributed four songs.’When I Live My Dream’ which had been performed in the original stage production back in 1967. ‘Columbine’ and ‘Harlequin’ were composed specifically for the TV performance. ‘Threepenny Pierrot’ was a rewrite of ‘London Bye, Ta-Ta’, a song that Bowie had first recorded back in 1968 and re-recorded a number of times until 1970.
The remainder are mixes of songs and single versions. Once again, this is a more comprehensive box set of the album and shows that if the artist or a record label had had the inclination, they could have produced this for themselves. The material was out there. I suspect there is a bit more in the archive, such as demos, which we will no doubt never hear. Shame.
Disc 1 – 1970 Album Mix & Singles
- The Width Of A Circle
- All The Madmen
- Black Country Rock
- After All
- Running Gun Blues
- Saviour Machine
- She Shook Me Cold
- The Man Who Sold The World
- The Superman
- The Prettiest Star (Original Mono Single Version)
- Holy Holy (Original Mono Single Version)
- Memory Of A Free Festival (Part 1) (Single Version)
- Memory Of A Free Festival (Part 2) (Single Version)
Disc 2 – 1990 Remaster & BBC Session
- The Width Of A Circle
- All The Madmen
- Black Country Rock
- After All
- Running Gun Blues
- Saviour Machine
- She Shook Me Cold
- The Man Who Sold The World
- The Superman
- London Bye, Ta-Ta (1970 Stereo Mix/2021 Remaster)
- Waiting For The Man (Sounds of the Seventies: Andy Ferris Show – 25th March 1970)
- The Width Of A Circle (Sounds of the Seventies: Andy Ferris Show – 25th March 1970)
- The Wild Eyed Boy From Freecloud (Sounds of the Seventies: Andy Ferris Show – 25th March 1970)
- The Superman (Sounds of the Seventies: Andy Ferris Show – 25th March 1970)
Disc 3 – 2015 Remaster
- The Width Of A Circle
- All The Madmen
- Black Country Rock
- After All
- Running Gun Blues
- Saviour Machine
- She Shook Me Cold
- The Man Who Sold The World
- The Superman
- Holy Holy (Mono 2015 Remaster)
- Memory Of A Free Festival (Part 1) (Single Version 2015 Remaster)
- Memory Of A Free Festival (Part 2) (Single Version 2015 Remaster)
- The Prettiest Star (Stereo Version)
- London, Bye, Ta Ta (Stereo Version)
- The Prettiest Star (Alt Mix)
- London Bye, Ta-Ta (Alt Stereo Mix)
Disc 4 – 2020 Remixes & Sessions
- The Width Of A Circle (Metrobolist)
- All The Madmen (Metrobolist)
- Black Country Rock (Metrobolist)
- After All (Metrobolist)
- Running Gun Blues (Metrobolist)
- Saviour Machine (Metrobolist)
- She Shook Me Cold (Metrobolist)
- The Man Who Sold The World (Metrobolist)
- The Superman (Metrobolist)
- The Prettiest Star (2020 Mix)
- London Bye, Ta-Ta (2020 Mix)
- Memory Of A Free Festival (Single Version 2020 Mix)
- All The Madmen (Single Edit 2020 Mix)
- Holy Holy (2020 Mix)
- London Bye, Ta-Ta (2021 Remaster)
Disc 5 – BBC Sessions
- Amsterdam (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- God Knows I’m Good (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Buzz The Fuzz (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Karma Man (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- London Bye, Ta-Ta (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- An Occasional Dream (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- The Width Of A Circle (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Janine (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Wild Eyed Boy From Freecloud (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Unwashed & Somewhat Slightly Dazed (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Fill You Heart (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- The Prettiest Star (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Cygnet Committee (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- Memory of a Free Festival (The Sunday Show Introduced by John Peel – 5th February 1970)
- When I Live My Dream (The Looking Glass Murders: AKA Pierrot in Turquoise)
- Columbine (The Looking Glass Murders: AKA Pierrot in Turquoise)
- Harlequin (AKA The MIrror) (The Looking Glass Murders: AKA Pierrot in Turquoise)
- Threepenny Pierrot (The Looking Glass Murders: AKA Pierrot in Turquoise)
- When I Live My Dream (Reprise) (The Looking Glass Murders: AKA Pierrot in Turquoise)
I did not include all of the variations of this album, especially not the RCA CD release from the early 1980s which I have not heard, but is meant to be terrible. I am sure that there is the odd stray track out there that I did not include as it was most probably hidden on an obscure compilation somewhere. Please let me know in the comments if I have done so. However, this just goes to show what could have been produced if Bowie or his record labels had taken the time and care to produce one of these for the 50th Anniversary back in 2020. Another missed opportunity I feel.
















